Suppose a self-employed Richmond buyer is shopping at a $400,000 price point (an illustration, not market data). Her business deposits about $11,000 a month into her account, and she has six figures in savings. Her tax return, after depreciation, a vehicle write-off and a home office deduction, shows net income of about $3,400 a month. The agency underwriting system declines her. She isn’t unqualified in any real sense. Her paperwork just doesn’t describe how she earns.
Non-QM is the loan program built for cases like hers. It uses alternative documentation, such as bank statements, 1099s, a CPA-prepared P&L, assets, or property rent, to prove income without relying on tax returns. It is not “no-doc” or “stated income”: the lender must still make a documented, good-faith determination that you can repay. Duane Buziak, NMLS #1110647, sorts each file between agency loans and non-QM, drawing on hundreds of wholesale lenders, and picks the documentation method that fits how you actually get paid.
Some terms first. A qualified mortgage (QM) meets federal standards under the CFPB’s Ability-to-Repay rule, which requires lenders to verify your ability to repay. A non-QM loan falls outside those product and underwriting boxes but is still underwritten to that standard.
- 1. Rule out FHA, VA and conventional before going non-QM
- 2. Qualify with bank statements instead of tax returns
- 3. Use 1099 income documentation
- 4. Document income with a CPA- or tax-preparer-prepared P&L
- 5. Qualify on assets with asset depletion
- 6. Qualify on property cash flow with a DSCR loan
1. Rule out FHA, VA and conventional before going non-QM
Agency loans usually cost less than non-QM, so they get tested first. Underwriters don’t take the bottom line of your return at face value. They add back certain non-cash or non-recurring deductions, such as depreciation, depletion, and some one-time expenses, and then average the result over two years. A return that looks weak can produce a much stronger qualifying number than you expect.
For example, imagine a Richmond consultant whose returns show low taxable income because of depreciation on equipment and a vehicle write-off. After add-backs, her averaged monthly income may comfortably support a conventional loan. In that case, going non-QM would mean paying a higher rate for no reason. The 2026 conforming limit of $832,750 (set by FHFA) also means most Richmond city purchases fall inside conventional limits, so size is rarely the obstacle. FHA self-employment rules are laid out in the HUD Handbook 4000.1, and they require a documented history of self-employment, generally two years. If you want to see how the three agency programs stack up on price first, our mortgage rate comparison of FHA, VA and conventional is a useful benchmark.
Here is how to run the test:
- Collect two years of personal and business returns, with all schedules, and a year-to-date profit and loss statement.
- Have Duane Buziak calculate qualifying income with the allowed add-backs and compare it with agency requirements for your target payment.
- Review your credit standing through a NoTouch Credit Pull, a soft-pull review that shows where you stand without a hard inquiry.
- If the agency number falls short, move to the non-QM method that fits your income type.
The common mistake is assuming that low taxable income means automatic non-QM. Sometimes it does, particularly when income dropped in the most recent year or write-offs were cash expenses. But skipping the add-back math can mean paying a higher rate unnecessarily.
Measure two things: whether qualifying income after add-backs clears your target payment under agency guidelines, and the payment gap between the agency scenario and the non-QM quote. If the gap is small, you may choose non-QM for flexibility. If it’s large, it’s worth tightening the file to fit an agency loan.
2. Qualify with bank statements instead of tax returns
Bank statement programs measure income by what actually lands in your account. The lender totals 12 or 24 months of deposits and averages them. For personal accounts, the deposits may count more directly. For business accounts, the lender applies an expense factor, a percentage of deposits treated as business costs, so only the remainder counts as income.
The factor is where the real money is. Imagine a Richmond contractor whose business account averages $20,000 in monthly deposits. With a flat 50% expense factor, qualifying income is $10,000. If a CPA letter supports a 30% expense ratio and the lender accepts it, qualifying income rises to $14,000. Same deposits, a $4,000 monthly difference in buying power. Contractors weighing this route can also see how agency programs treat their income in our guide to getting a mortgage as a self-employed contractor.
Preparing the file well matters more than almost anything else in this strategy:
- Pull complete statements, every page of every month, including blank pages. Missing pages stall underwriting.
- Keep business and personal accounts separate, and identify which account the lender will use.
- Mark transfers between your own accounts, loan proceeds, refunds, and one-time deposits so they can be excluded cleanly.
- Ask up front whether the lender will accept a CPA letter to set the expense factor, and what the letter must say.
The classic mistake is commingling personal and business funds, or leaving large unexplained deposits in the review period. Underwriters exclude what they can’t source, and every excluded dollar shrinks your income. If a big deposit is legitimate, such as a one-time sale of equipment, document it before you apply rather than after a condition is issued. A self-employed mortgage documentation checklist can help you gather everything in one pass.
Track average monthly qualifying deposits after exclusions, and the debt-to-income ratio that results at your target payment. If deposits are volatile, compare the 12-month and 24-month averages. The longer period can lower or raise the figure depending on your trend, so ask for both.
3. Use 1099 income documentation
Independent contractors, gig workers, and commissioned earners often receive 1099s instead of W-2s. A 1099 program qualifies you on one or two years of those forms, sometimes backed by a year-to-date earnings statement. Some programs apply an expense adjustment to the gross figure, and some don’t. That detail varies by lender, so it should be confirmed before you choose a program.
The mechanism is simple: 1099s are third-party records of what you were paid, which makes them strong evidence even when your return deducts heavily. Imagine an independent sales consultant who works with several clients and receives 1099s from each. Her return shows large deductions for travel, software, and a home office, which pull her taxable income down. A 1099 program looks at the gross payments, a client list, and a steady pattern of earnings, and it may value her income more accurately than the return does. Earners paid mostly on variable pay face similar questions, which we cover in proving commission-based income for a mortgage.
To build the file:
- Gather every 1099 for the period, including any 1099-NEC and 1099-K forms.
- Prepare a year-to-date income summary showing payments received this year.
- Write a short explanation of your work history, your clients or platforms, and how long you’ve done this work.
- Ask whether the lender applies an expense factor and, if so, whether a CPA letter can adjust it.
The mistake that sinks the most applications is applying shortly after switching from W-2 to 1099 work, with no history and no explanation. Underwriters want to see that the income is repeatable. If you moved from a salaried job into the same field as a contractor, say so plainly, and include the prior W-2 history, since it shows continuity in the same line of work. Our overview of a recent job change and your mortgage application explains how underwriters view that kind of transition.
Measure two things: how consistent your 1099 income is year over year, and how many payers contribute. One client supplying 90% of your earnings is a concentration risk that underwriters will notice, so a spread across several payers strengthens the file.
4. Document income with a CPA- or tax-preparer-prepared P&L
A profit and loss statement covers a stretch of 12 or 24 months and shows revenue minus expenses. When it’s prepared and signed by a licensed professional, such as a CPA or an enrolled agent, many non-QM programs accept it in place of returns. It matters most when your returns lag behind your business.
Take a growing Richmond business owner (an illustration). Her last filed return is a year old and shows income far lower than she earns today, because the business has expanded since. A CPA-prepared P&L covering the last 12 months captures that run rate. Underwriting on the old return would punish her for growth that has already happened. Owners in this position may also want our mortgage guide for small business owners in Richmond.
This method depends on credibility, so the preparation steps matter:
- Engage the CPA or enrolled agent early. Year-end and tax season can make professionals hard to book.
- Ask the lender how it verifies the preparer’s license, how long the preparer must have worked with you, and which period the P&L must cover.
- Have the preparer build the statement from your books, not from estimates.
- Compare the P&L against your bank deposits before submitting, and resolve any gap.
The costly error is submitting a self-prepared spreadsheet, or a P&L that conflicts with your bank statements. Underwriters compare the two. If the P&L claims $18,000 a month in revenue and the deposits show $11,000, the file can be denied late in underwriting, after you’ve paid for an appraisal and locked a rate. Knowing how the mortgage underwriting process works helps you anticipate those cross-checks.
The measure is reconciliation: do P&L revenue and income line up with your deposit totals within a reasonable margin? Differences can have legitimate explanations, such as invoices paid late or cash held in a separate account. Know the explanations in advance and put them in writing.
5. Qualify on assets with asset depletion
Some buyers have wealth and little current income: retirees living off savings, sellers of a business, or people between ventures. Asset depletion converts eligible liquid assets into a notional monthly income. The lender takes the qualifying balance, applies its own formula, and counts the result as income against your debt-to-income ratio. The formula, the eligible asset types, and any haircuts on stocks or retirement accounts are set by the lender, so they differ from program to program. This sits within the broader category of non-traditional income home loans.
Imagine a retiree with a large brokerage account and no pension. She has no paycheck for an underwriter to verify, but a portion of her portfolio, run through the formula, produces a monthly income figure that supports the payment. The underwriting question becomes whether the assets are real, documented, and sufficient.
To prepare:
- Gather statements for the period the lender requires, for every account you may use.
- Ask which assets are eligible. Cash and marketable securities are usually treated differently from retirement accounts or business equity.
- Confirm whether the same assets can also support your down payment and reserves, and by how much.
- Check your credit standing with a NoTouch Credit Pull before any hard inquiry, especially if you haven’t borrowed in years.
The mistake to avoid is counting the same dollars three times: as qualifying income, as your down payment, and as reserves. Once cash goes toward the down payment, it leaves the pool the formula draws from. Run the numbers in sequence so that the post-closing balance still supports the income you claimed.
Measure the qualifying monthly income the formula produces, and set it against the assets remaining after closing. If the formula barely clears your target and your cushion is thin, a smaller loan or a larger down payment from other funds may be wiser than stretching.
6. Qualify on property cash flow with a DSCR loan
A debt service coverage ratio (DSCR) loan is for investment properties only. Underwriting looks at the property, not your personal income: the expected rent is compared with the property’s full monthly payment, and if the rent covers it by the lender’s minimum margin, the property qualifies. Personal tax returns and pay stubs generally aren’t part of the income analysis, which is why investors with heavy write-offs use it. Buyers eyeing small rental buildings may also find our guide to multi-family property mortgages in Richmond relevant.
The ratio is rent divided by payment. Suppose an investor buys a Richmond rental where the appraiser’s market rent is $2,400 and the full monthly payment, including principal, interest, taxes, insurance, and any HOA dues, is $2,200. That is a DSCR of about 1.09. Whether that clears depends on the lender’s minimum, which varies, and some programs accept ratios at or below 1.0.
Prepare as follows:
- Order a rent schedule with the appraisal so the market rent is documented independently.
- Assemble the real figures for property taxes, insurance, and HOA dues. An understated payment will mislead your own math.
- Ask for the lender’s minimum DSCR and how it treats vacant or newly leased units.
- Ask about prepayment penalties, how long they last, and how they are calculated.
Two errors come up repeatedly. The first is treating DSCR as an option for a home you’ll live in. It isn’t: it’s for investment property. The second is ignoring prepayment penalty terms. If you plan to sell or refinance within a few years, a penalty can cost real money.
Measure the DSCR against the lender’s minimum, then look past it to actual cash flow after all expenses, including maintenance, vacancy, and management. A property can clear the ratio and still lose money month to month. For rate context across all of these programs, the Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey tracks the conventional rate environment, which is the benchmark for the agency alternative you tested first.
Start with the agency test, then match the method to your income
Confirm agency eligibility first. It costs you nothing but a document request, and it may save you from a pricier loan. If the numbers fall short, pick the non-QM documentation method that matches how you really earn: bank statements for business deposits, 1099s for contractor income, a CPA-prepared P&L when returns lag, asset depletion when savings outweigh income, and DSCR for rental property. Then gather your statements or your CPA-prepared P&L before you apply, because clean paperwork shortens underwriting. Non-QM generally costs more than agency financing, and terms vary by lender, so compare options before you commit. Dare to Compare, and look at the whole payment, not just the headline rate.
Whether you’re a veteran ready to use your hard-earned benefits or a homebuyer exploring your financing options, your path to homeownership starts with expert guidance you can trust. Connect with Duane today for a personalized consultation and discover the mortgage solution tailored to your unique goals in the Stafford County and Richmond area.
