Duane Buziak

Duane Buziak
Mortgage Maestro | NMLS #1110647 | Coast2Coast Mortgage LLC
Licensed mortgage broker serving Virginia, Florida, Tennessee, Georgia, Washington DC, North Carolina, South Carolina, and Maryland, specializing in VA home loans and first-time homebuyer programs.

Suppose you buy a Richmond home at $350,000, a round illustrative price in the range of city-level figures from Zillow and Virginia REALTORS (check the current median before running your own numbers). A conventional loan at 5% down means $17,500 down and about $2,214 a month for principal, interest, and PMI, using an illustrative 6.25% rate. A lender-held portfolio loan at 20% down and 7.00% means $70,000 down and about $1,863 a month. The payment is lower, but you need $52,500 more cash at the table.

That trade-off is why this is a program-vs-program decision. Conventional conforming loans, which are sold to Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, are the baseline. A portfolio loan is the exception that needs a defined reason. Duane Buziak, NMLS #1110647, built the seven strategies below so you can test that reason before you commit. VA and FHA loans are separate government-backed programs and are not portfolio products.

1. Start with conventional conforming eligibility

Conventional conforming loans follow Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac guidelines, and the volume of loans sold to them is why pricing is usually tightest here. In 2026 the baseline conforming limit is $832,750 (FHFA). Any loan inside that limit that meets the guidelines should be priced first, because it becomes the yardstick for everything else.

Consider an illustration: a W-2 buyer with a 700 credit score and 5% down at a Richmond median-priced home. Automated underwriting approves the file, the buyer pays PMI for a while, and that PMI is not permanent. Under the Homeowners Protection Act, PMI terminates automatically when the balance is scheduled to reach 78% of the home’s original value, and you can request cancellation at 80% (CFPB). No portfolio loan was needed.

To test your eligibility:

  1. Gather two years of W-2s, recent pay stubs, and two months of bank statements.
  2. Run a soft-pull pre-approval with NoTouch Credit Pull, so your score is not dinged while you shop.
  3. Compare your target price and loan amount to the $832,750 limit.
  4. Ask for the payment with PMI included, not principal and interest alone.

The common mistake is deciding you need a specialty loan before testing conventional guidelines. Many buyers who assume they are “unusual” turn out to fit. Measure success by two things: a conventional pre-approval at your target price, and a payment inside your budget. If you get both, you can stop here.

2. Identify the specific guideline gap

A portfolio loan is a mortgage the lender keeps on its own books instead of selling, so the lender writes its own underwriting rules. That flexibility only helps if you know which rule you need bent. Common gaps are income that is hard to document, a credit event, a high DTI, a property type, or a loan size outside the conforming range.

Two misconceptions are worth clearing up. Portfolio loans are not automatically cheaper or easier; flexibility is usually priced in. And a portfolio loan is not the same thing as a jumbo loan. Some jumbo loans are held in portfolio, others are sold to investors, and plenty of portfolio loans are not jumbo at all.

Illustration: a borrower had a recent credit event and has strong assets. Conventional underwriting applies waiting periods that run years after events like a foreclosure (see the current Fannie Mae Selling Guide for exact timelines), and the buyer’s timing cannot absorb that. A lender that weighs the assets more heavily might fit.

  1. List every conventional denial or concern in writing.
  2. Ask your loan officer which specific guideline triggers each one.
  3. Ask whether a fix exists, such as waiting a few months, paying down a card, or documenting an income source differently.

The pitfall is choosing a portfolio loan for convenience when a short fix would restore conventional eligibility. Paying a higher rate for years to avoid a ninety-day wait is a poor trade. The measure here is simple: you should be able to write down one documented reason the portfolio route is needed. If you cannot, go back to strategy 1.

3. Compare the total cost, not just the rate

A rate is one input. Fees, mortgage insurance, down payment size, and prepayment terms all shape what you actually pay, and they pull in different directions depending on how long you stay.

Worked example: $350,000 Richmond purchase, 7-year horizon

These rates are illustrative, not quotes. For current market averages, see Freddie Mac’s weekly PMMS. Fees are excluded so the comparison isolates rate, PMI, and down payment.

The monthly gap is $350.66 in the portfolio loan’s favor, and the cash gap is $52,500 against it. Over 84 months, the conventional borrower pays $171,970 in principal and interest plus $13,965 in PMI, and the loan balance falls to about $299,400. That is roughly $152,800 in interest and PMI. The portfolio borrower pays $156,479 and the balance falls to about $255,200, which is roughly $131,700 in interest. The portfolio loan costs about $21,100 less to borrow, but only because you put in $52,500 more. If that cash would earn more elsewhere or is your emergency fund, the answer changes.

To run your own version:

  1. Request Loan Estimates for both products.
  2. Compare APR and Sections A, B, and C (origination charges, services you cannot shop for, and services you can shop for) as laid out in the CFPB’s Loan Estimate guidance.
  3. Model total cost at 5 and 10 years, including any prepayment penalty.

The mistake is comparing only the headline rate. Measure total cost over your realistic holding period, plus APR.

4. Match the loan to your income documentation style

Conventional underwriting wants income it can verify and average. That works well for salaried borrowers and can work against people whose real cash flow is larger than their taxable income.

Illustration: a self-employed buyer writes off heavily, so two years of tax returns show low net income. Under conventional rules, qualifying income is the averaged figure after deductions, and the DTI fails. A lender with alternative documentation might use twelve or twenty-four months of bank deposits instead, which shows a higher usable income.

  1. Collect two years of tax returns, a current profit-and-loss statement, and twelve to twenty-four months of business and personal bank statements.
  2. Ask each path how it calculates income: net after deductions, average of deposits, or a percentage of gross receipts.
  3. Confirm which documents each lender accepts and whether a CPA letter is needed.
  4. Run the DTI on each result.

The pitfall is assuming bank-statement qualification is available everywhere or carries no premium. It is not offered by every lender, it often requires a larger down payment, and the rate is usually higher than conventional. Because Duane Buziak works as both a broker and a lender, he can check which documentation options exist across hundreds of wholesale lenders before you spend time on a path that does not exist.

Measure qualifying monthly income and the resulting DTI under each path. If the alternative path gives you a workable DTI but at a rate that erases the benefit, strategy 3’s math will show it.

5. Use a portfolio loan for property types conventional rejects

Sometimes the borrower is fine and the property is the problem. Conforming loans require the collateral to meet investor standards. A condo that fails them is called non-warrantable, meaning Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac will not buy loans on it. Typical triggers include a high share of investor-owned units, one owner holding too many units, pending litigation, or too much commercial space in the building. Some unusual properties, such as mixed-use or those with unconventional condition, also fall outside conforming rules.

Illustration: a buyer falls for a condo in a project with high investor concentration. The project fails warrantability review, and conventional financing is off the table. The buyer asks for a lender-held loan, which may accept the project but usually comes with a larger down payment and a higher rate.

Before you write an offer:

  1. Ask your loan officer to check the project’s eligibility early, before you spend money on inspections.
  2. Request the condo questionnaire and budget documents from the management company.
  3. Get the lender’s property rules, including minimum down payment and any reserve requirements, in writing.

The most expensive mistake is writing an offer before confirming project or property eligibility, then discovering the financing contingency is about to expire. Measure project approval status against the financing deadline in your contract. If approval is not in hand with comfortable time to spare, ask for an extension in writing.

6. Plan your exit: adjustments, prepayment, and refinance

Many portfolio loans are not plain 30-year fixed products. They may be fixed for five years and then adjustable, or carry a balloon payment. The loan is often designed to be a bridge, which means the exit is part of the product.

Illustration: a borrower takes a 5-year fixed-then-adjustable portfolio loan, planning to refinance into a conventional loan at year three once credit has recovered. The plan works only if the refinance is possible and the exit does not cost more than it saves.

  1. Read the adjustment caps (first adjustment, periodic, and lifetime), any balloon date, and the prepayment terms.
  2. Calculate the worst-case payment if the loan adjusts to its cap.
  3. Set a refinance review date, say month 30, and note what you need by then: credit score, income documentation, and equity.
  4. Track those three items every quarter.

The common mistake is overlooking a prepayment penalty that cancels out the refinance savings. If the penalty runs through year five and you refinance in year three, the fee can consume the benefit. Check whether it applies to a refinance, a sale, or both.

Measure the penalty-free window against your planned refinance date, and the worst-case adjusted payment against your budget. If the worst case does not fit, the loan is a gamble, not a bridge.

7. Get side-by-side quotes before you commit

Rates and pricing move daily, so quotes from different days are not comparable. A fair comparison needs the same price, the same down payment where possible, the same credit assumptions, and the same date.

Illustration: two Loan Estimates dated the same day for the same $350,000 price. The conventional one shows a lower APR and lower fees but needs PMI. The portfolio one shows a higher APR, a larger cash to close, and a lower monthly payment. Neither is “right” until you see them next to each other.

  1. Request both estimates through Richmond Home Loans by Duane Buziak, using NoTouch Credit Pull so shopping does not add inquiries to your report.
  2. Line them up: rate, APR, points or credits, cash to close, and monthly payment including PMI.
  3. Ask about the Dare to Compare challenge, which puts a competing Loan Estimate next to Duane’s for an itemized comparison.
  4. Ask each side to confirm what assumptions it used, including lock period and credit score tier.

The mistake is comparing quotes from different days or with different assumptions about points and credits. One quote with a point paid and another without is not a rate comparison. Measure APR, cash to close, and monthly payment across the two estimates, and decide which one matches your holding period from strategy 3.

Portfolio loan vs conventional mortgage at a glance

FeatureConventional Conforming LoanPortfolio Loan
Who holds the loanUsually sold to Fannie Mae or Freddie MacKept by the lender
Underwriting rulesStandardized investor guidelinesSet by the individual lender
Down paymentAs low as 3% to 5% for eligible buyersOften 10% to 25% or more, varies by lender
Mortgage insurancePMI below 20% down; cancels at 78% scheduled LTVVaries; some lenders require larger down payments instead
Rate and pricingUsually the pricing baselineOften higher to price in flexibility, but not always
Income documentationTax returns, W-2s, verified incomeMay allow bank statements or other documents
Property typesMust meet conforming and warrantability standardsMay accept non-warrantable condos or unusual properties
Loan sizeUp to $832,750 in 2026 for the baseline limitAny size the lender will hold
Prepayment penaltyUncommonMore common; read the terms
Typical fitBuyers who meet standard guidelinesBuyers with a documented guideline gap

Frequently asked questions

What is a portfolio loan?

A portfolio loan is a mortgage the lender keeps on its own books instead of selling it, so the lender sets its own underwriting rules.

Is a portfolio loan cheaper than a conventional mortgage?

Not usually; portfolio loans often carry higher rates or larger down payment requirements because the lender is taking on risk the investors would not.

Is a portfolio loan easier to qualify for?

Only for specific situations, such as hard-to-document income or a non-warrantable condo, and the lender can still decline.

Is a portfolio loan the same as a jumbo loan?

No, because a jumbo loan is defined by size above the conforming limit, while a portfolio loan is defined by who holds it.

What is the 2026 conforming loan limit?

The 2026 baseline conforming loan limit is $832,750, according to FHFA.

When does PMI come off a conventional loan?

PMI terminates automatically when the balance is scheduled to reach 78% of the home’s original value, and you can request cancellation at 80% (CFPB).

Are VA and FHA loans portfolio loans?

No, VA and FHA loans are government-backed programs with their own rules, not lender-held portfolio products.

What is a non-warrantable condo?

A non-warrantable condo is a unit in a project that fails Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac standards, for reasons such as high investor concentration or pending litigation.

Can I refinance a portfolio loan into a conventional loan?

Often yes, if you meet conventional guidelines at that point and the prepayment terms do not erase the savings.

Does comparing loan options hurt my credit?

A soft-pull pre-approval with NoTouch Credit Pull does not affect your score, and a formal application can follow once you pick a path.

Confirm conventional first, then price both

Confirm conventional eligibility first. If you qualify, you have your baseline and may not need anything else. If you do not, name the guideline gap, then price both options on a same-day Loan Estimate so the numbers are fair. Only then decide whether a portfolio loan earns its premium.

Whether you’re a veteran ready to use your hard-earned benefits or a homebuyer exploring your financing options, your path to homeownership starts with expert guidance you can trust. Connect with Duane today for a personalized consultation and discover the mortgage solution tailored to your unique goals in the Stafford County and Richmond area. Contact Richmond Home Loans by Duane Buziak to get both estimates side by side.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *